Why it works
Judge the decision, not just the result.
Six-Pointer brings the hiring discipline of the big technology companies to transfers. Here is the research behind each part, and what we don't claim.
Start from a written brief
Structured assessments are among the strongest predictors of job performance in workplace research. Unstructured interviews come out at less than half the validity: .42 against .19.
In Six-Pointer: Every signing starts from a written brief: the role, the minutes expected and the budget.
Source: Sackett et al., 2022
Each view before anyone else's
When people see each other's views first, opinions converge and confidence rises, without accuracy improving.
In Six-Pointer: Each person gives their view and its reason before seeing anyone else's.
Source: Lorenz et al., 2011
Combine views by a rule
Combining independent assessments by a consistent rule has outperformed holistic judgement in selection research, even when the experts knew the job well.
In Six-Pointer: Your club sets its own test of a sound decision, and every signing is checked against the same test. The call stays yours.
Source: Kuncel et al., 2013
More than one opinion
Research on football scouts finds low agreement between scouts watching the same players, so one opinion is a weak basis for a multi-million-pound decision.
In Six-Pointer: Your test can ask for more than one kind of evidence and more than one scout's report before a signing.
The decision apart from the result
People judge the same decision more harshly when it turns out badly.
In Six-Pointer: Every review answers two questions separately: was it a sound decision with what you knew then, and how did it turn out?
An independent check before sign-off
Amazon has used independent Bar Raisers and written feedback before group discussion since 1999. Google separates interviewers from the people who make the hiring decision.
In Six-Pointer: A Process Steward from outside the first-team staff checks your test before sign-off. They can pause a decision; they can't stop it.
Reasons that outlast the manager
The average English league manager lasts under two years.
In Six-Pointer: Every decision is locked with its reasons, so they are still there when the manager has gone.
Source: AJ Bell, January 2026
Track whose calls hold up
Tracking forecasters' records and grouping the best has measurably improved forecasting accuracy.
In Six-Pointer: Every scout's calls are checked against the matches that followed.
Source: Mellers et al., 2014
What we don't claim. We don't claim Six-Pointer makes signings succeed. There is no evidence for that yet. We will collect it with the clubs we work with, and show it when we have it. These methods have not yet been tested in the EFL.
Each source is the published study or the company's own account. Six-Pointer is a trading name of Hikari AI Ltd (company no. 15408552).