Demo: a fictional club, scouts and players, to show how the page reads.
Archive Audit · Kingsmere City (demo)
The ones that
got away.
In 5 seasons your scouts wrote about 139 players. 35 moved up a level. You signed 4. These are the 31 that got away, and who, if anyone, called each one first.
- 01
31 got away.
Within three seasons of a scout first seeing them, they went on to play a level higher for another club. - 02
12 were called in time.
A scout said sign before they moved up. For the other 19, nobody said sign in time. - 03
2 everyone passed on.
Every report on them said not for us. Worth a look at why. - 04
Their sign calls beat the usual rate.
When they said sign, 47% moved up, against about 29% for players like these.
Got away
Who they were.
Where they were when your scout first saw them, where they went, and what was said at the time. Facts, not blame: the reasons are your scouts' own words.
Ciaran Foulkes
Level 6 → Level 4 · moved up 2022/23 · now Sefton Park
First seen Jul 2021 by Dan Kerridge: Sign
First to say sign: Dan Kerridge, Jul 2021
Ade Edevane
Level 5 → Level 3 · moved up 2022/23 · now Brackley Moor
First seen Mar 2022 by Dan Kerridge: Sign
First to say sign: Dan Kerridge, Mar 2022
Callum Kolawole
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2022/23 · now Stourford
First seen Oct 2019 by Steve Hale: Watch again
First to say sign: Dan Kerridge, Oct 2021
Rhys Edevane
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2021/22 · now Sefton Park
First seen Feb 2020 by Dan Kerridge: Sign
First to say sign: Dan Kerridge, Feb 2020
Ben Sutcliffe
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2020/21 · now Brackley Moor
First seen Apr 2020 by Steve Hale: Sign
First to say sign: Steve Hale, Apr 2020
At the time: “Gets caught on the ball.”
Toby Foulkes
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2023/24 · now Hesketh Wanderers
First seen Jul 2021 by Dan Kerridge: Sign
First to say sign: Dan Kerridge, Jul 2021
Kai Rourke
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2022/23 · now Oldbridge
First seen Jul 2021 by Sophie Lang: Sign
First to say sign: Sophie Lang, Jul 2021
Toby Kolawole
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2023/24 · now Brackley Moor
First seen Dec 2021 by Sophie Lang: Sign
First to say sign: Sophie Lang, Dec 2021
At the time: “Presses from the front all game.”
Show all 31 +
Femi Brenner
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2022/23 · now Oldbridge
First seen Jan 2022 by Steve Hale: Sign
First to say sign: Steve Hale, Jan 2022
Rhys Yates
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2025/26 · now Coldharbour
First seen Jul 2022 by Steve Hale: Sign
First to say sign: Steve Hale, Jul 2022
José Benton
Level 2 → Level 1 · top · moved up 2025/26 · now Calder United
First seen Nov 2022 by Marcus Bell: Sign
First to say sign: Marcus Bell, Nov 2022
Reece Byrne
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2023/24 · now Wyre Valley
First seen Apr 2023 by Dan Kerridge: Sign
First to say sign: Dan Kerridge, Apr 2023
Ciaran Lindqvist
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2021/22 · now Sefton Park
First seen Dec 2019 by Priya Nair: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Nathan Doak
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2022/23 · now Stourford
First seen Jan 2020 by Steve Hale: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Gets caught on the ball.”
Lewis Benton
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2020/21 · now Coldharbour
First seen Jan 2020 by Steve Hale: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Jake Rees
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2020/21 · now Wyre Valley
First seen Apr 2020 by Priya Nair: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Rhys Nwosu
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2020/21 · now Oldbridge
First seen Jun 2020 by Marcus Bell: Not for us
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Drifts out of games for long spells.”
Josh Byrne
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2023/24 · now Dunmore Town
First seen Jul 2020 by Dan Kerridge: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Joel Venn
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2022/23 · now Wyre Valley
First seen Jul 2020 by Marcus Bell: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Saw Joel Venn at Brindle Rovers last night.”
Ben Edevane
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2023/24 · now Ellesby Town
First seen Aug 2020 by Steve Hale: Not for us
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Clean technique under pressure.”
Kai Venn
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2022/23 · now Hesketh Wanderers
First seen Mar 2021 by Steve Hale: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Nathan Quigley
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2023/24 · now Hesketh Wanderers
First seen Apr 2021 by Priya Nair: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Brave in possession, always wants the ball.”
Owen Hensall
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2022/23 · now Stourford
First seen Aug 2021 by Steve Hale: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Clean technique under pressure.”
Jake Marchant
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2022/23 · now Stourford
First seen Nov 2021 by Dan Kerridge: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Reece Ridley
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2022/23 · now Coldharbour
First seen Nov 2021 by Dan Kerridge: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Ellis Sutcliffe
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2024/25 · now Wyre Valley
First seen Mar 2022 by Steve Hale: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Mateo Tarrant
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2023/24 · now Oldbridge
First seen Jun 2022 by Dan Kerridge: Not for us
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Struggles against physical opponents.”
José Ashdown
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2025/26 · now Hesketh Wanderers
First seen Mar 2023 by Dan Kerridge: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Kieran Abbott
Level 6 → Level 5 · moved up 2024/25 · now Ellesby Town
First seen Apr 2023 by Dan Kerridge: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Alfie Kettleby
Level 5 → Level 4 · moved up 2025/26 · now Oldbridge
First seen May 2023 by Sophie Lang: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
Reece Yates
Level 4 → Level 3 · moved up 2024/25 · now Stourford
First seen May 2023 by Sophie Lang: Watch again
Nobody said sign before they moved up.
At the time: “Too slow to recover when we lose it.”
Who called it
Each scout's sign calls.
Each dot is a player that scout said sign to, before they moved. Lit: they moved up. Ringed: you signed them. Too few calls each for a percentage, so we show the count, and how many the usual rate would expect.
Dan Kerridge
6 of 12 moved up · about 3 expected for players like these
6 got-away players called first
Sophie Lang
4 of 10 moved up · about 3 expected for players like these
2 got-away players called first
Steve Hale
4 of 12 moved up · about 3 expected for players like these
3 got-away players called first
Priya Nair
2 of 8 moved up · about 2 expected for players like these
Marcus Bell
1 of 4 moved up · about 1 expected for players like these
1 got-away player called first
From here
Stop the next ones getting away.
The Black Box records each decision as it's made, and reviews it every three months. Next time, the call and what happened are joined up from the first day.
Moved up: played league football a level higher for another club, including on loan, within three seasons of the first report, in the same country. Going up with their own club's promotion, or back to the club that loaned them, doesn't count. Got away: moved up, and not signed by you. "Called in time": a scout said sign in a season before they moved up. Under-18s are never shown. No transfer fees are used: the cost of waiting can only come from your own records.